Antibiotics impose massive displacement on bacterial populations: D(_antibiotic) is the degree of departure from the pre-antibiotic bacterial fitness landscape. The bacterial response—rapid evolution of resistance—is gradient descent on D(_antibiotic), restoring fitness in the new antibiotic environment. Antibiotic resistance is not a medical failure; it is evolution working exactly as predicted.
MRSA (Staphylococcus aureus resistant to methicillin) and other resistant pathogens are wrong attractors: bacterial states that have converged on high antibiotic resistance and maintain themselves against continued antibiotic challenge. The microbiome ground state S^0_microbiome is the diverse community of commensal bacteria living in symbiosis with the host. Antibiotics devastate S^0_microbiome even when targeting pathogens, because the drugs cannot distinguish commensal from pathogen.
Microbiome disruption is the unintended D(_microbiome) cost of antibiotic therapy. We develop the formal displacement framework for antibiotic resistance, map MRSA and Clostridium difficile as canonical wrong attractors, analyze horizontal gene transfer as rapid resistance-displacement propagation, characterize the agricultural antibiotic system as the dominant global source of D(_resistance), and argue that phage therapy represents the minimally-disruptive alternative consistent with the framework.
Phronesis